{"api":{"name":"api.sb","description":"Business-as-Code surface for Startups.Studio","home":"https://api.sb","docs":"https://api.sb/docs","version":"1.0.0"},"$context":"https://api.sb/$context","$type":"FoundingHypothesis","$id":"https://api.sb/founding-hypotheses/fh%3Afilm-and-video-editors-vfx-comp-review%3At-low%3Av1","links":{"self":"https://api.sb/v1/founding-hypotheses/fh%3Afilm-and-video-editors-vfx-comp-review%3At-low%3Av1","canonical":"https://api.sb/founding-hypotheses/fh%3Afilm-and-video-editors-vfx-comp-review%3At-low%3Av1","pool":"https://api.sb/v1/founding-hypotheses"},"foundingHypothesis":{"id":"fh:film-and-video-editors-vfx-comp-review:t-low:v1","lens":"CoPilot","type":"founding-hypothesis","click":{"rubricScores":{"C8_lensFit":1,"C7_magicLensFit":1,"C4_competitorHonesty":1,"C6_crossSlotCoherence":1,"C1_customerSpecificity":1,"C2_problemFrictionRealism":1,"C9_killCriteriaAttestability":1,"C3_approachEngineCoverability":1,"C5_differentiationLoservilleEscape":1},"upperRightLoserville":true},"cellRef":{"id":"work-contexts.org.ai/film-and-video-editors-vfx-comp-review","stableHash":"wcc:film-and-video-editors:vfx-comp-review:multimodal:v1"},"problem":{"slotStatement":"When a showrunner rejects a hero shot at final-delivery review and asks 'why did this note from turnover v03 not get addressed,' the VFX Sup cannot reconstruct which client note was dispositioned, by whom, against which plate version, because approval state lives scattered across Frame.io comments, ShotGrid Notes, Zoom transcripts, and Slack DMs — leaving the studio exposed on overage invoices and vendor-package audits."},"approach":{"oneSentence":"Sitting behind ShotGrid and Frame.io, a shot-disposition ledger watches every comp iteration, client annotation, and supervisor decision, then certifies each approval with the plate-hash, note-author, and version lineage a producer can pull up during a delivery dispute."},"customer":{"icpShape":"Boutique VFX and post-production studios (company-type-solo-dental-practice class: owner-operator shops of 8-40 comp artists servicing episodic TV and streaming shows), where the buyer is the VFX Executive Producer or Head of Studio who signs the vendor MSA and the daily user is the VFX Supervisor / Lead Compositor driving dailies and client review sessions in Nuke and ShotGrid.","beachheadShape":"EarlyAdopterJTBD: boutique episodic-TV VFX shops delivering 40-120 shots per episode on SVOD schedules where client-side approval notes arrive via Frame.io, email, and Zoom recordings with no unified approval ledger."},"archetype":"startup-archetypes.org.ai/CoPilot-Subscription","beachhead":"EarlyAdopterJTBD: boutique episodic-TV VFX shops delivering 40-120 shots per episode on SVOD schedules where client-side approval notes arrive via Frame.io, email, and Zoom recordings with no unified approval ledger.","competitors":{"substitutes":[{"name":"Autodesk Flow (ShotGrid) Review + Notes","category":"incumbent","uncopyabilityReason":"ShotGrid's Notes and Review modules treat annotations as free-text records tied to a Version entity, not as dispositioned decisions with plate-hash lineage; shipping a genuine approval ledger would require Autodesk to re-architect the Version/Note schema that the entire ShotGrid customer base and all third-party pipeline tools (Shotgun Toolkit, tk-multi-publish2) depend on — integration-depth lock-in with their own ecosystem prevents a clean cut."},{"name":"Frame.io (Adobe) C2C + Review","category":"incumbent","uncopyabilityReason":"Frame.io's business is Camera-to-Cloud capture and web review for editorial, not VFX shot state reconciliation — it has no awareness of Nuke scripts, render passes, or plate versions, and Adobe's distribution-channel is Creative Cloud seat bundling to editors, not studio-bid VFX pipelines. Rebuilding a comp-aware approval lineage would cannibalize their editor-first positioning and require data-corpus access to VFX pipeline metadata they do not collect."},{"name":"ftrack Review","category":"incumbent","uncopyabilityReason":"ftrack is deployed as a multi-tenant SaaS review tool optimized for animation/VFX project tracking, but its approval records are statuses on Version entities, not cryptographically linked dispositions across plate+comp+note triplets. Shipping the winning quadrant requires on-prem-adjacent deployment inside the studio's Perforce/SAN perimeter — a deployment-mode mismatch with ftrack's cloud-only architecture."},{"name":"Per-show Google Drive / SMB share as approval binder","category":"manual-bridge"},{"name":"Producer emailing Zoom recording + PDF of Frame.io notes to client","category":"informal"}]},"studioThesis":"T-LOW","killThreshold":{"K":8,"M":65,"N":8,"rubricItemSet":["C1_customerSpecificity","C2_problemFrictionRealism","C3_approachEngineCoverability","C4_competitorHonesty","C5_differentiationLoservilleEscape","C6_crossSlotCoherence","C7_magicLensFit","C8_lensFit","C9_killCriteriaAttestability"],"verdictPolicy":"all-load-bearing-pass-and-overall-ge-X","loadBearingItemSet":["C1_customerSpecificity","C2_problemFrictionRealism","C3_approachEngineCoverability","C4_competitorHonesty","C5_differentiationLoservilleEscape","C6_crossSlotCoherence","C9_killCriteriaAttestability"],"verdictPolicyVerbatim":"KILL unless every load-bearing rubric item passes per workbook AND overall pass-rate ≥ 8/9 (CASCADE.md §4 Stage 9 commit threshold)."},"lifecycleState":"Active","differentiation":{"twoByTwo":{"xAxis":"Pipeline integration depth (web-review overlay only ↔ bound to Nuke scripts, plate hashes, and ShotGrid Versions)","yAxis":"Approval object model (free-text note on a Version ↔ dispositioned decision linking note-author + plate-hash + comp-iteration)","winningQuadrant":"Decisions bound to plate-hash + comp-iteration lineage, wired into the Nuke/ShotGrid pipeline the studio already runs, so any producer can answer 'which note, which version, who approved' in under 30 seconds during a delivery dispute","loservilleEscape":true,"loservilleQuadrant":"Frame.io-style free-text web annotations sitting on top of an MP4 proxy with no linkage to the underlying Nuke script or plate version — exactly where a showrunner's v03 note gets lost between turnovers"}},"unmetRequirements":[],"pricingArchitecture":"single-price"},"actions":{},"options":{},"relationships":{"runtimeUnit":"https://api.sb/v1/runtime-units?startupRef=startup%3Afh%3Afilm-and-video-editors-vfx-comp-review%3At-low%3Av1","brand":"https://api.sb/v1/brands?startupId=startup%3Afh%3Afilm-and-video-editors-vfx-comp-review%3At-low%3Av1","listing":"https://api.services/listings?foundingHypothesisRef=fh%3Afilm-and-video-editors-vfx-comp-review%3At-low%3Av1","cell":"https://api.sb/v1/cells/work-contexts.org.ai/film-and-video-editors-vfx-comp-review","thesis":"https://api.sb/v1/theses/T-LOW"},"meta":{"level":"L0","scopes":[]},"user":{"requestId":"a0575b17ba42284b","edgeLocation":"a0575b17ba42284b","geo":{"country":"US"},"ua":{"browser":"Claude"}},"references":{"total":0,"limit":25,"page":1,"links":{"self":"https://api.sb/v1/founding-hypotheses/fh%3Afilm-and-video-editors-vfx-comp-review%3At-low%3Av1/references"},"items":[]}}