{"api":{"name":"api.sb","description":"Business-as-Code surface for Startups.Studio","home":"https://api.sb","docs":"https://api.sb/docs","version":"1.0.0"},"$context":"https://api.sb/$context","$type":"FoundingHypothesis","$id":"https://api.sb/founding-hypotheses/fh%3Afirstline-supervisors-of-production-and-operating-workers-production-schedule-adjustment%3At-low%3Av1","links":{"self":"https://api.sb/v1/founding-hypotheses/fh%3Afirstline-supervisors-of-production-and-operating-workers-production-schedule-adjustment%3At-low%3Av1","canonical":"https://api.sb/founding-hypotheses/fh%3Afirstline-supervisors-of-production-and-operating-workers-production-schedule-adjustment%3At-low%3Av1","pool":"https://api.sb/v1/founding-hypotheses"},"foundingHypothesis":{"id":"fh:firstline-supervisors-of-production-and-operating-workers-production-schedule-adjustment:t-low:v1","lens":"AIService","type":"founding-hypothesis","click":{"rubricScores":{"C8_lensFit":1,"C7_magicLensFit":1,"C4_competitorHonesty":1,"C6_crossSlotCoherence":1,"C1_customerSpecificity":1,"C2_problemFrictionRealism":1,"C9_killCriteriaAttestability":1,"C3_approachEngineCoverability":1,"C5_differentiationLoservilleEscape":1},"upperRightLoserville":true},"cellRef":{"id":"work-contexts.org.ai/firstline-supervisors-of-production-and-operating-workers-production-schedule-adjustment","stableHash":"wcc:firstline-supervisors-of-production-and-operating-workers:production-schedule-adjustment:document:v1"},"problem":{"slotStatement":"When a turbine trips, a feedstock lot fails QC, or a crew calls out mid-shift, the supervisor verbally reshuffles the production schedule over the radio and in a paper shift-log — the upstream planner, the downstream dispatcher, and the next shift's supervisor each learn about the constraint hours later (or never), so the same rework gets re-triggered two or three times per week and the root-cause note dies on the queue."},"approach":{"oneSentence":"Shift-board reconciliation that listens to the supervisor's radio dispatch and MES events, certifies each schedule deviation against the originating constraint (equipment trip, QC hold, crew-availability gap), and routes a verifiable handoff note to the next shift and to planning before the board changes hands."},"customer":{"icpShape":"Public utilities (CompanyType/company-type-public-utility) — specifically investor-owned electric and water utilities with 500–5,000 field operations staff running 24/7 generation, treatment, or distribution plants, where the buyer is the VP of Operations or Plant Manager (controls the MES/shift-management tooling budget) and the daily user is the first-line production supervisor running the shift board.","beachheadShape":"EarlyAdopterJTBD: investor-owned electric utilities with multi-site generation fleets where a PUC rate case or NERC reliability audit has already exposed undocumented schedule deviations in the last 18 months."},"archetype":"startup-archetypes.org.ai/AIService-UsageMetered","beachhead":"EarlyAdopterJTBD: investor-owned electric utilities with multi-site generation fleets where a PUC rate case or NERC reliability audit has already exposed undocumented schedule deviations in the last 18 months.","competitors":{"substitutes":[{"name":"Paper shift-log + radio handoff","category":"manual-bridge","uncopyabilityReason":""},{"name":"Ironclad-style contract repository (bridge pattern noted upstream)","category":"informal","uncopyabilityReason":""},{"name":"GE Proficy Plant Applications (MES shift management module)","category":"incumbent","uncopyabilityReason":"Proficy is architected around deterministic OPC-UA tag ingestion and pre-modeled production routes; capturing a supervisor's verbal schedule reshuffle requires a voice + free-text reasoning layer that sits outside Proficy's tag-based data model, and GE's deployment-mode mismatch (on-prem historian tied to plant-floor PLCs) means adding a cloud LLM reconciliation path would require re-architecting the plant-floor trust boundary that their utility customers contractually depend on."},{"name":"AVEVA Manufacturing Execution System (formerly Wonderware MES)","category":"incumbent","uncopyabilityReason":"AVEVA's integration depth is with the PI historian and SCADA layer, not with the human coordination layer — their product roadmap is gated by OSIsoft/PI data-model compatibility commitments that lock them out of shipping a supervisor-voice reconciliation workflow without breaking backwards compatibility for the 20-year installed base of refinery and utility customers who bought on historian fidelity."},{"name":"Shiftconnector (eschbach) digital shift handover","category":"incumbent","uncopyabilityReason":"Shiftconnector is a structured-form shift-handover tool sold into pharma and chemicals with a vertical-data-corpus built around batch-record templates; its template library and validation posture are GxP-shaped, not NERC/PUC-shaped, and re-training the model + re-certifying the compliance posture for electric-utility schedule deviations would require a utility-specific reliability-event corpus the company does not hold."},{"name":"Microsoft Copilot / ChatGPT Enterprise used ad-hoc by supervisors","category":"AI-native horizontal","uncopyabilityReason":"Horizontal LLMs have no integration-depth into the plant MES, CMMS (Maximo), or shift-scheduling system (Kronos/Workday), so they cannot observe the actual constraint event or route the reconciled note back into the work-order system — closing that gap requires per-utility OT/IT network crossings and a liability posture for advising on safety-critical schedule changes that Microsoft and OpenAI explicitly disclaim."}]},"studioThesis":"T-LOW","killThreshold":{"K":10,"M":65,"N":7,"rubricItemSet":["C1_customerSpecificity","C2_problemFrictionRealism","C3_approachEngineCoverability","C4_competitorHonesty","C5_differentiationLoservilleEscape","C6_crossSlotCoherence","C7_magicLensFit","C8_lensFit","C9_killCriteriaAttestability"],"verdictPolicy":"all-load-bearing-pass-and-overall-ge-X","loadBearingItemSet":["C1_customerSpecificity","C2_problemFrictionRealism","C3_approachEngineCoverability","C4_competitorHonesty","C5_differentiationLoservilleEscape","C6_crossSlotCoherence","C9_killCriteriaAttestability"],"verdictPolicyVerbatim":"KILL unless every load-bearing rubric item passes per workbook AND overall pass-rate ≥ 7/9 (CASCADE.md §4 Stage 9 commit threshold)."},"lifecycleState":"Active","differentiation":{"twoByTwo":{"xAxis":"Handoff capture surface (structured-form entry only ↔ passive capture of radio voice + MES events + supervisor free text)","yAxis":"State-reconcile cadence (end-of-shift batch report ↔ continuous per-deviation reconcile before the next dispatch)","winningQuadrant":"Passive multi-surface capture with continuous per-deviation reconcile — the next shift and the planner see the updated constraint within minutes of the supervisor speaking it, not at 7am handover","loservilleEscape":true,"loservilleQuadrant":"Structured-form-only capture with end-of-shift batch rollup — Shiftconnector's GxP form model and Proficy's tag-only ingestion both sit here, which is exactly why silent schedule losses survive the handoff queue today"}},"unmetRequirements":[],"pricingArchitecture":"usage-meter"},"actions":{},"options":{},"relationships":{"runtimeUnit":"https://api.sb/v1/runtime-units?startupRef=startup%3Afh%3Afirstline-supervisors-of-production-and-operating-workers-production-schedule-adjustment%3At-low%3Av1","brand":"https://api.sb/v1/brands?startupId=startup%3Afh%3Afirstline-supervisors-of-production-and-operating-workers-production-schedule-adjustment%3At-low%3Av1","listing":"https://api.services/listings?foundingHypothesisRef=fh%3Afirstline-supervisors-of-production-and-operating-workers-production-schedule-adjustment%3At-low%3Av1","cell":"https://api.sb/v1/cells/work-contexts.org.ai/firstline-supervisors-of-production-and-operating-workers-production-schedule-adjustment","thesis":"https://api.sb/v1/theses/T-LOW"},"meta":{"level":"L0","scopes":[]},"user":{"requestId":"a0575b08bfdf284b","edgeLocation":"a0575b08bfdf284b","geo":{"country":"US"},"ua":{"browser":"Claude"}},"references":{"total":0,"limit":25,"page":1,"links":{"self":"https://api.sb/v1/founding-hypotheses/fh%3Afirstline-supervisors-of-production-and-operating-workers-production-schedule-adjustment%3At-low%3Av1/references"},"items":[]}}